Art History Lab

The Resurgence of Kitsch Art: Embracing Sentimentality in Modern Expression

Kitsch Art: A Brief Exploration of Its Definition, Rejection, and Appreciation

Do you remember those tacky paintings of weeping clowns or nostalgic landscapes that hung in your grandmother’s house? Have you ever seen those porcelain figurines of chubby-cheeked toddlers or doilies with cutesy embroidered slogans?

These are just some examples of what we call “kitsch.” But what exactly is kitsch, and why does it evoke such strong reactions from people? In this article, we will delve into the definition of kitsch art, how it has been rejected by avant-garde movements, and the current re-appreciation of kitsch as a valid art form.

Kitsch Art Definition

Kitsch art is defined as an unsophisticated imitation or a shallow identification with popular culture objects that leads to an excessive expression of bad taste. The term kitsch is derived from the German word “kitschen,” which means to make cheap, shallow art.

Kitsch is often characterized by its sentimental and emotional appeal, typically aimed at eliciting a specific reaction from the viewer. These types of artwork are often simplistic, predictable, and formulaic in their execution, which sets them apart from high art or fine art.

Examples of kitsch art can range from paintings to sculptures, decorative objects to fashion, and even film and literature.

Avant-garde Rejection

Kitsch art has been a controversial subject in the art world, as it has been rejected by avant-garde movements, like Dadaism and Surrealism, for being a shallow and banal ideals of beauty. These avant-garde movements opposed the values of mainstream culture, which they saw as perpetuating aesthetic and intellectual mediocrity.

They saw kitsch as an embodiment of these values, representing a regressive form of art that lacked originality, creativity, and critical reflection. Avant-garde artists sought to challenge and disrupt traditional artistic conventions by pushing the boundaries of what was considered acceptable, meaningful, and beautiful.

Re-Appreciation of Kitsch Art

Despite the avant-garde’s rejection of kitsch, it has re-emerged in recent years as a valid form of art. Kitsch art is now celebrated for its offer of conscious satire of banal objects, as well as its comic, sincere ways.

Kitsch can be viewed as a way to critique the establishment and poke fun at the social norms that people value. This shift in perspective can be traced back to the rise of Pop art in the 1960s, which sought to challenge the elitism of fine art by incorporating elements of popular culture into artistic expression.

Derogatory Term for Visual Art

Although kitsch art has been diminished as a derogatory term for visual art, the experience of viewing such art can still be a pleasant and genuine one. Kitsch can evoke warm memories of one’s youth, provide comfort in times of uncertainty, or simply offer aesthetic pleasure.

Famous examples of kitsch paintings include Norman Rockwell’s sentimental portrayals of idyllic American life and Thomas Kinkade’s romanticized landscapes, lit up as if by a heavenly aura. These paintings are often panned by critics for their lack of artistic merit, but their widespread popularity attests to their emotional appeal to a wide range of people.

In conclusion, kitsch art is a complex and multifaceted subject that has been both rejected and re-embraced by the art world. Its definition as an offering of sentimental and shallow art pervades popular imagination, but its deliberate re-appropriation as a satirical and comedic form has challenged the notion of what we consider high art.

Ultimately, the enjoyment of kitsch art is subjective and depends on the individual viewer’s tastes and experiences.

Origins of Kitsch Art

The origins of kitsch art can be traced back to the Munich art market in the 19th century. At this time, there was a high demand for inexpensive and fashionable images and drawings that could be produced quickly and sold to the masses.

In response to this need, enterprising artists began creating works that emphasized sentimentality and idealization, with subjects such as picturesque landscapes, cute animals, and romanticized scenes of everyday life. These works were often characterized by their pleasant and easily recognizable imagery, making them highly marketable and popularized among the general public.

Kitsch as Technical Expression

While kitsch is often regarded as a form of lowbrow, shallow art, it has been argued that kitsch can also be considered as an essential element of technical expression. In the early 20th century, Germany was experiencing a period of experimentation in the arts that saw the emergence of a style referred to as “new objectivity.” This movement placed a particular emphasis on the technical aspects of art-making, seeing the creation of art as a form of skilled labor rather than a means of self-expression.

Kitsch art became recognized as a type of technical expression, with its production demonstrating a high degree of skill and attention to detail. Hermann Broch’s Definition of Kitsch

Hermann Broch, an Austrian writer, provided a definition of kitsch that has been influential in shaping our understanding of this art form.

According to Broch, kitsch is mimetic, meaning that it copies and imitates existing forms of art and culture. However, it does so without any critical reflection or ethical dimension.

Kitsch separates the product from the observer, creating a sense of artificiality that ultimately leads to a lack of empathy between the two. Broch saw kitsch as a fraud and argued that it offered a false sense of comfort and meaning to consumers.

Fraudulent Art

The creation of kitsch art can be viewed as an attempt to fool the customer, offering an artificial representation of reality that bears little resemblance to actual experience. Critics argue that kitsch art promotes sentimental feeling and nostalgia through the use of formulaic techniques, which can lead to the creation of fraudulent emotions and experiences.

However, it is also argued that the role of the viewer is important in this process. The viewer can choose to embrace the sentimental aspects of kitsch or reject them outright, and this decision ultimately shapes the meaning and value of the artwork.

In conclusion, kitsch art is a diverse and complex art form that has been characterized by its sentimental and formulaic qualities. Its origins in the Munich art market demonstrate its historical significance, while its recognition as a form of technical expression highlights its artistic value.

The definition and understanding of kitsch have been shaped by influential thinkers such as Hermann Broch, who saw kitsch as fraudulent and lacking ethical dimension. However, the role of the viewer in interpreting and experiencing kitsch remains key to shaping our understanding of this art form.

Tom Kulka’s Conditions for Kitsch Art

Tom Kulka, an art historian, identified three conditions that define kitsch art. These include an attractive or highly emotive topic, easy identification for the viewer, and a lack of enrichment in the connections between the many elements in the artwork.

According to Kulka, these conditions result in the creation of a shallow and facile form of art that is easily recognizable but lacks depth and complexity.

Excessive Emotion and Melodrama

Kitsch art is often associated with excessive emotion and melodrama. It has been labeled as derogatory due to its simplistic and predictable nature.

Critics argue that kitsch art appeals to the lowest common denominator and panders to the masses, offering a misleading view of reality that lacks substance and critical reflection. This derogatory labeling highlights the incompatibility of kitsch art with the traditional definition and understanding of art.

Subjectivity of Art

Art is subjective, and the definition of art varies from person to person. Some people might view kitsch art as frivolous and lacking artistic merit, while others might find it enjoyable and sentimental.

Different perspectives on kitsch art have emerged over the years, with some viewing it as a form of lowbrow art, while others see it as a valid form of artistic expression. Contemporary artists have incorporated kitsch elements into their work, further complicating our understanding of this art form.

Purposeful Inclusion of Kitsch

Some artists have purposefully included kitsch elements in their artwork, using them as a means of commenting on the superficiality of modern culture. The enjoyment of kitsch can also lead to a sense of nostalgia and a sense of community, with viewers connecting over shared experiences and memories.

The subjective nature of art means that different viewers will have different reactions to kitsch art. Still, it is essential to recognize that kitsch can hold value within certain contexts and is not necessarily an inferior form of artistic expression.

In conclusion, kitsch art can be both valued and derided, depending on the viewer’s perspective. The incorporation of kitsch elements by contemporary artists demonstrates that the definition and understanding of art are fluid and constantly evolving.

Kitsch art offers a particular mode of artistic expression that appeals to a wide range of viewers and can hold sentimental value. However, its association with shallow and superficial qualities means that it has often been dismissed by traditional art critics and theorists.

Ultimately, the enjoyment of kitsch art lies in the eye of the beholder, reflecting the subjective nature of the art world and its many dimensions.

The Kitsch Movement

In recent years, there has been a movement to redefine kitsch art positively, rather than seeing it as inferior to fine art. Artists such as Odd Nerdrum have been at the forefront of this movement, seeing kitsch as a valid form of artistic expression that has a philosophical foundation.

The Kitsch Movement seeks to elevate the value of kitsch art by emphasizing the skill, technique, and creativity involved in its creation.

Kitsch Art as Societal Commentary

Kitsch art can be seen as a form of societal commentary, with artists using the medium to comment on politics, environmental issues, and social environments. Kitsch lends itself well to this form of expression due to its populist tendencies, allowing artists to reach a broader audience and connect with shared experiences.

By incorporating kitsch elements into their work, artists can bring attention to social issues and promote critical reflection.

Role of Kitsch Art in Society

Kitsch art can serve a vital role in society by providing a democratic assessment of artistic preferences. The popularity and accessibility of kitsch art can be seen as a reflection of societal tastes and values.

As such, the wider appreciation of kitsch art can lead to a broader understanding of democratic choices and artistic interpretation. The role of kitsch art can also extend to political choices, with artists using kitsch to comment on political issues or celebrate historical events.

Kitsch as Inclusivity

Kitsch art can widen the appreciation of fine arts by making art accessible to a wider audience. The simplicity and directness of kitsch can help overcome the barriers to understanding classic works of art and can also attract those that may feel excluded from the fine arts community.

Kitsch can serve as an inclusive form of art, allowing a wider audience to engage with artistic expression and interpretation. In conclusion, the redefinition of kitsch art emphasizes its artistic value and philosophical foundation rather than dismissing it as shallow and superficial.

Kitsch art can provide vital societal commentary on politics, environmental issues, and social environments while also serving a broader role in democratic assessments of artistic preference. Kitsch art can also be viewed as inclusive, making art accessible to a wider audience and encouraging a broader appreciation of art forms outside of the exclusive fine arts community.

Ultimately, the rise of the Kitsch Movement and the wider appreciation of kitsch art reflect the ever-changing nature of art and the impact of societal changes on artistic interpretation.

Examples of Famous Kitsch Paintings

Several famous kitsch paintings have captured the public’s imagination and become iconic representations of this art form. One such example is Vladimir Tretchikoff’s “Chinese Girl,” also known as “The Green Lady.” This 1950 portrait of a young Chinese woman with vibrant green skin became one of the best-selling and widely recognized paintings in the world.

Its sentimental portrayal and exotic subject matter appealed to a wide audience, making it a quintessential example of kitsch art. Another notable work is “The Return of the Sun” by Odd Nerdrum.

This painting depicts a mythical scene of light and warmth radiating from a central figure. The use of dramatic lighting, intense emotions, and mythical symbolism aligns with the elements often found in kitsch art.

Nerdrum’s work blends traditional techniques with contemporary subject matter, creating a thought-provoking interpretation of kitsch art.

Examples of Contemporary Kitsch Paintings

Kitsch art is not limited to the past, as contemporary artists also incorporate kitsch elements into their work. One notable example is Bernard Buffet’s “Two Clowns,” a painting that showcases the artist’s signature style.

Buffet’s use of exaggerated figures with elongated features and bold colors adds a touch of whimsy and theatricality to his art, making it a prime example of contemporary kitsch. Another renowned contemporary kitsch painter is Jack Vettriano, known for his romantic and nostalgic compositions.

His famous work, “The Singing Butler,” captures a scene of two elegantly dressed individuals dancing on a windswept beach. The painting’s sentimental storyline, evocative atmosphere, and incorporation of popular culture references make it a beloved example of contemporary kitsch.

Jeff Koons is another artist who produces artworks that straddle the line between kitsch and fine art. His “Balloon Dog” sculptures, in particular, have gained international recognition.

These large-scale stainless-steel sculptures are inspired by children’s party balloons and are depicted in vibrant, metallic finishes. Koons’ playful and accessible approach to sculpture blurs the boundaries between kitsch and high art, challenging conventional notions of artistic value.

In conclusion, famous kitsch paintings have left an indelible mark on the art world and popular culture. Whether it is Tretchikoff’s “Chinese Girl” or Nerdrum’s “Return of the Sun,” these artworks continue to resonate with audiences due to their sentimental appeal and identifiable imagery.

Contemporary artists like Buffet, Vettriano, and Koons also add to the legacy of kitsch art, exploring its possibilities in the modern era. Kitsch art’s ability to evoke emotion, comment on societal issues, and simultaneously challenge and embrace popular culture ensures its continued relevance and fascination in the world of art.

In conclusion, kitsch art is a diverse and multifaceted form of artistic expression that has sparked controversy and debate throughout history. While it has often been dismissed as shallow and lacking in artistic merit, the redefinition and re-appreciation of kitsch art have demonstrated its value and relevance.

From its origins in the Munich art market to the rise of contemporary kitsch, artists have utilized kitsch art to comment on society, provide inclusive artistic experiences, and challenge traditional notions of beauty and value. The appreciation of kitsch art is subjective, and its enjoyment lies in the eye of the beholder.

As we continue to explore and engage with this unique form of art, let us embrace its complexity, celebrate its sentimental appeal, and recognize the role it plays in shaping our understanding of artistic expression and societal values.

Popular Posts